When selecting a material for printing a bicycle mount or a garden sensor box, the choice usually narrows down to PETG and ASA. Both have a reputation as durable plastics, but each is suitable for slightly different applications and prints differently. Based on our experience from testing on our own printers, we will look at how these two materials differ in practice and what they can withstand in demanding conditions.


UV radiation and weather resistance
UV resistance is the most common reason for switching from PETG to ASA. PETG is suitable for outdoor use. It resists water, does not deform in normal summer heat and resists chemicals. If a hose holder or a bird feeder is printed from it, it will last in the garden for several years. The problem arises after a longer period in direct sunlight. UV radiation gradually disrupts the PETG structure, the material becomes brittle and colors can fade. After two years, this process is already noticeable.
ASA material is specifically designed to resist UV radiation and weathering. It is commonly used in the automotive industry for exterior plastics. An ASA part retains its properties even after years in direct sunlight. It does not become significantly brittle or yellow. For building a weather station or printing parts for a caravan, ASA is a more suitable choice.
Temperature resistance
The difference in temperature resistance is crucial when printing car parts. PETG softens at temperatures around 70 to 76 °C. For garden use, this value is sufficient. However, the dashboard of a car parked in the summer sun can heat up to 80 °C. A PETG phone holder will deform in such conditions.
ASA handles temperatures up to roughly 95 to 100 °C. Car parts, covers for hot engine components or various industrial applications will withstand such high temperatures. The properties are similar to ABS, but with added UV resistance. For a detailed comparison with ABS, we have prepared a separate article.
Printing difficulty
There is a significant difference in printing difficulty between the materials. PETG can be printed on most standard printers without the need for an enclosure. We recommend setting the nozzle to 220 to 250 °C and the bed to 70 to 85 °C. PETG adheres strongly to a smooth PEI sheet, so we recommend using a glue stick as a separator, or printing on a textured sheet. Stringing can occur when printing PETG. This phenomenon can be reduced by slower retraction and thoroughly drying the filament. We dry the material ourselves at 65 °C for approximately 4 to 6 hours.
ASA is significantly more demanding to print. The nozzle temperature should be 240 to 260 °C and the bed 90 to 110 °C. Using a printer with a closed enclosure is essential. Without an enclosure, larger ASA parts warp and detach from the bed. Print cooling must be either completely turned off or kept at a maximum of 10 to 20 %. We recommend applying a thin layer of glue to the bed. Styrene is released when printing ASA, so it is necessary to ensure adequate ventilation. More information on how to deal with 3D printing fumes can be found in our next article.
PETG and ASA at a glance
Relative rating 1 to 5 (higher = better) based on typical values and our printing experience.
PETG softens at roughly 70 to 76 °C, ASA around 95 °C. Print ASA in a closed chamber and ventilate.
Comparison table
| Property | PETG | ASA |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature resistance | approx. 70 to 76 °C | approx. 95 to 100 °C |
| UV resistance | Medium (becomes brittle over time) | Excellent (long-term) |
| Printer requirements | Open printer is sufficient | Enclosure required |
| Nozzle temperature | 220 to 250 °C | 240 to 260 °C |
| Bed temperature | 70 to 85 °C | 90 to 110 °C |
| Odor and fumes | Minimal | Releases styrene (ventilate) |
When to choose which material?
For printing common garden items such as hooks, tool holders, flower pots or boxes that will not be exposed to direct sunlight for long periods, we recommend choosing PETG. It is more affordable, easier to print, without significant odor and is fully sufficient for most common outdoor applications.
For printing car interior parts, drone components, roof weather stations or bicycle mounts that must withstand mechanical stress and sunlight for a long time, ASA is more suitable. The time invested in tuning the print and providing a closed enclosure will return in a longer lifespan of the printed part.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Is it necessary to dry ASA like PETG?
Yes. Both materials absorb moisture. We recommend drying ASA at 80 °C for approximately 4 hours. Wet material pops during printing and degrades surface quality.
Is ASA stronger than PETG?
Tensile strength is similar for both materials, but ASA better tolerates higher temperatures and long-term outdoor stress. PETG is slightly more flexible, while ASA is stiffer.
Can ASA be printed on a printer without an enclosure?
Small parts up to approximately 3 cm in size can be printed on an open printer. For larger models, the corners lift from the bed and the part can crack due to drafts and rapid cooling.
Can the ASA surface be smoothed?
Only partially. ASA reacts with acetone, but smoothing is not as effective as with ABS and the surface can become matte. PETG cannot be smoothed using acetone.
Why is ASA more expensive?
It is an engineering plastic with additives for UV stability, which is produced in smaller volumes than standard PETG (from €6.50 to €9.95 per 1 kg spool).